And how the hell would I be able to do that? [ He knew that there were files in there about all of them, but the clues that Komaeda left trying to hint him towards the truth were Bad. ]

We knew you found something, but without any hints, we couldn't possibly have guessed that we were the former Remnants of Despair!

[ It was a plot twist that none of them would have thought of if the AI Enoshima didn't shove it to them, as if it were a gift horse. ]

Then are you going to tell me why you hate it or are you just going to beat around the bush?